120 Seconds – The Two-Minute Book Report. (Remix)

Posted on January 13, 2010Filed Under cartoons, oral reading, presentations, Reading, Rerun | 2 Comments

This time (and next), it’s not quite a rerun. It’s more of a remix. Yeah, that’s it. Right now we’re in the midst (today was day 2) of our two-minute book reports. I posted about this last year about this time, so I’m going to use that previous post as the starting point, and embellish…

I have always hated “book reports.” (Wait, I told my wife I would try to stop using that word.) I didn’t like writing them (took all the fun out of the book), I didn’t like reading them back when I thought I had to assign them. I don’t like the summarize kind, the analyze kind, the combo kind, the form letter kind, or the “make a diorama” kind.  (Well, some of the dioramas I used to get WERE pretty cool; the Lego version of the murder in the graveyard in Tom Sawyer was very detailed and boss, and I still have a shoebox/popcicle stick Tom Sawyer whitewashing scene from 1995, a matchstick Outsiders hide-out church from 1994, and Tom and Becky lost in a shoe-box cave, complete with bats. But still… If you do like book reports or feel the “need” to assign them , here are some way less boring ideas.)  I figure KBAR takes care of most of my “need” to make them read/respond to books outside of class, and I certainly don’t need more work to grade. But I do see a large value in having the kids share with each other what they are reading and enjoying. They always need new material to try out.

I have also always disliked “presentations.” Especially long ones. After 10-15 minutes of whatever riveting presentations are being performed, the rest of the class (including yours truly) is fading and drifting. Then, they drag out over days, and interrupt the flow of everything else in the class, and while there can be significant learning during the prep for the presentation, there usually isn’t a whole lot of learning going on during the performances. Sorry, maybe I’m just a crab. But I do see the value in them rehearsing and getting up there and speaking in public.

Also;  the kids these days aren’t very good at reading aloud, and they hate getting up and making speeches. And both are skills they need to have, and the almighty standards include a public speaking element.

So. I wanted to take into account our (my) short attention spans and their need to share and find out about new books, and try to combine torturing them with some badly needed skills practice. Et voila!

120 Seconds.  Here’s the handout. Read it and come back. Fine. I see how it is. Teachers are worse than the kids about reading the directions.

I start with the carrot:

“How many of you like to do book reports?”

No hands. Well, there is sometimes one of those OCD readers — the ones who love to rack up Accelerated Reader points and churn out book reports — but they’re usually too busy reading surreptitiously to even hear me.

“Good. I don’t like reading them either.”

Then I bust the stick on them. Not literally. Not too much anyway.

120 Seconds. Half of it telling us about a great book they’ve read (are reading) — brief plot summary, why it’s cool, background of the excerpt, etc. Half of it reading a groovy passage from it. We have judges (3 + me and I average the scores), we have an uh counter (who also counts unnecessary likes, as in “he was, like, 17…”), and we have a timer.

2 minutes. That’s it. No time for padding. No time to hem and haw. No time for the crowd to get restless. You better be rehearsed, because you’re being judged. And if it’s a nightmare, it’s over in 120 seconds.

(Click to Enlarge.)

They get a week to prepare. I get a lot of questions about the level of difficulty.

“What would Harry Potter be? The Hobbit?”

“It would depend on the particular passage, pick one and show it to me before Tuesday. FYI, Hatchet is a two, Twilight is mostly a three I think – show me the passage, and Harry Potter and The Hobbit are mostly fours.  And unless you’re willing to read enough Romeo and Juliet to be able to explain your excerpt to us, you won’t be able to get the six that’s worth.”

(Waitaminute! Harry Potter and the Hobbit. Hmmmmmm. Sounds like Hollywood gold.)

And they ask a lot about the uh/umm/like counting. Sometimes even as they ask their questions, I just hold up a hand and start ticking off each time they say like or uh/umm. They get all flustered, and then they say it even more. It’s a real eye-opener for some of them.

(This remix is close to 800 words, and I have to go nigh nigh. More tomorrow, with examples!)

Comments

2 Responses to “120 Seconds – The Two-Minute Book Report. (Remix)”

  1. Theresa Milstein on January 14th, 2010 3:56 am

    Two minutes sounds doable for you and the students. As a student, I dreaded book reports, except the diorama as well. I spent more time on the diorama than the report.

  2. mrC on January 14th, 2010 10:25 pm

    Exactly my point! I, on the other hand, hated having to glue cardboard and paper and whatnot into the shape of whatever. Can’t I just write a paper?

Leave a Reply